Kids Are People Too.

When I picked Little One up from school yesterday he was, in fact, fully-clothed in clothing that were not his jammas. Including socks. And boots. And all the other necessary parts of “being dressed”. His teacher reported that he did it all by himself and that he was perfectly cheerful all day.

He ran out of the classroom door and attacked me in a bear hug (as he always does) and started jabbering away about his day and his friends and who didn’t get ready on time and then he said, “.. And TOMORROW I will get up and get dressed in CLOTHES for SCHOOL!”

This morning he was up and dressed before Coffee and I got out of bed.

Clearly he was SERIOUS about that getting ready thing.

It never stops amazing me, seriously, how transient kids’ moods are from moment to moment and day to day.

Speaking of clothing, Middle One came home wearing his teacher’s gloves after school.

When asked, he asserted that his hands were cold (from not wearing mittens) and so his teacher had offered his own so Middle One wouldn’t be cold during lunch and recess.

Each of our kids own at least 2 pairs of gloves/mittens that are theirs alone – they’re responsible for not losing them, for not wrecking them, and for knowing where they are each morning. If they manage to lose the gloves/mittens, they are expected to use their allowance to purchase a new pair.

In addition, we have about 8 pairs of “family gloves/mittens” that can be borrowed when personal gloves are lost in a heap of dirty laundry or still wet from sledding. These are kept in a container in the living room.

Every day, Middle One is reminded that it’s cold outside and there is snow and that it would be a good idea to wear mittens or bring some with him in his backpack in case he gets cold. He chooses whether or not to wear them or bring them or just leave without them.

(The other kids are given the same reminder and choice, too, but in Little One’s case we put them into his bag for him.)

This is part of our “natural consequences” parenting style. We make sure they kids have their own items, then we remind them when it’s appropriate to use/take them, they choose and then they live with consequences. They can always make a different choice the next day – and sometimes they do. Other times they decide that they really didn’t need the mittens or gloves or warmer sweater (or whatever).

I wrote a note to Middle One’s teacher thanking him for caring about our kid’s cold fingers, of course, and gave him a rundown of the glove situation around here. I asked him to please not assist Middle One beyond telling him to “make better choices the next day” if need-be.

Middle One is, without question, the least organized kid I’ve ever known and he has absolutely no worries about it. He’ll shrug off losing almost anything. We are working really hard to help him learn to keep his stuff in the right places, where he can find it again, and to teach him how to be responsible.

We have yet to have a full school day with no tears.

Every day Middle One either cries on the way to or from school – for a variety of reasons that include “Older One is looking at me”, “The snow is too cold”, “I broke my X or Y toy”, “I fell”, “I forgot my X or Y at school” and other, more creative, offerings.

The kicker is that he won’t TELL me he’s upset; he’ll just slog along the sidewalk sobbing until I notice (he’s one of those people who cries quietly until he gets really worked up) and then be offended that I didn’t notice him crying a block earlier.

And every day I hear myself say, “Middle One? Why are you crying?” and “What would you like me to do?”

Yesterday we made it all the way to school without tears. Then we made it all the way to our backyard before he found a reason to cry.

I call this progress.

On the flip side, Little One used to cry several times each day. If he was frustrated, he’d cry. If he was mad, he’d cry. If he was tired, he’d cry. If someone breathed his air, he’d cry.

Lately he’s gone a whole day here and there without any tears at all. And yesterday was just ONE cry.

And the best part is that his tears are no longer epic dramas of hysterical shrieking – they’re two-minute bouts of tears, a few sniffles, and then he comes for a hug and feels better right away.

He is using his words to tell me what’s wrong. He believes me when I say we can fix the problem together.

I call this progress, too.

Oldest One is getting into the swing of this “homework thing” each day. I’ve been helping him with math, in particular, and I’m stunned by the crap they’re forcing the kids to learn. Yugh.

Every day that I take him to school I feel worse about the education he’s getting.

We live in a world where facts and figures are easily discovered on the internet and where calculators exist. I want my kids to know how to use the tools that are available once they have the basic concepts under their belts.

Basic concepts? Well, I believe it’s important to know things like multiplication and division. I believe it’s important to know how to spell. I believe it’s important to know how to research things and find answers much more than I believe it’s important to memorize stuff.

I’m just not sure that multiple-page worksheets in which he’s expected to convert the size of mountains in kilometers to millimeters is useful. Or decimeters, for that matter. When was the last time YOU used decimeters for.. ANYTHING?

So he scrawls his answers and I bite my tongue and he asks me, honestly, if I’ve ever needed to do this sort of math in my adult life. And I tell him, honestly, no.

The homeschooling concept looms ever-closer.

Let me be clear – I do not fault his teachers. They have curriculum to follow. They work hard to make that curriculum interesting, engaging and appropriate. And, god knows they can’t customize every lesson to each individual kid.

I know a lot of people who have attended regular ol’ school and excelled and learned well and gone on to be very successful. I’m not knocking the public school system!

I’m just not sure that it’s serving MY kids very well. Coffee and I need to discuss this. Figure things out.

One of the concepts drilled into our heads in our adoption-parenting-training was the idea of “raising adults not children”. That we, like all parents, need to focus on teaching our kids how to be good adults and not how to be good kids.

This doesn’t mean that we don’t let them play or have fun or enjoy themselves. They ARE kids.

But they will someday be adults. And they will need to have the right skills to be successful adults. Childhood ends and the kids need to be prepared for things like “going to work every day” and “taking care of paying the bills” and “things cost money” and all the rest.

Kids are people. They’re not a special brand of people – they’re.. people. They need to be treated with respect and to have their feelings and thoughts and opinions count for something. I think the best way to treat them with respect is to help them get to adulthood in one piece and to learn how to work with the mind and body they’ve been given.

One size does not, in fact, fit all.

Balancing three kids with three different personalities/needs/desires is difficult. I don’t think it’s impossible, though.

  1. Melle’s avatar

    Measuring in decimeters might not be of any use, but learning how to convert and calculate is.

    While I heartily agree that there’s plenty of crap taught in school that NO ONE needs to know, I also think (in hindsight) that there are many things valuable in theory and process, if not in example.

    I was pondering this just the other day, in fact, when perusing a Facebook group for York Theatre alumni, and reading responses posted to the question of whether or not people have used/are using their theatre degrees.

    Reply

  2. stroppycow’s avatar

    The page of conversion is to give them an idea about using the right unit for varying sizes. You know that putting the size of a mountain in mm is silly but most children do not know that until they have seen for themselves the huge number of 0 and the risk of forgetting on to realise that using a larger unit is more appropriate. It’s also practice for multiplying and dividing by multiples of 10. The amounts to do is because most children who find the concept difficult to grasp eventually get it through repetition.
    You will probably see the preparatory work that leads up to it in Middle One’s homework. Mainly to do with getting an idea of scale and measurements, using an arbitrary unit (a piece of string for example). Also if the school has a themed approach to subjects you will probably find it links in with some Design & Technology (or whatever they call it in .ca) or Geography work Oldest One will be doing soon or in parallel.

    I feel your pain though… we had loads of homework tears last night.

    Reply

  3. Jo’s avatar

    Jo’s opinion on MATH:

    Math is awesome! Math every day in big or littlle or important or unimportant ways… is AWESOME!

    Let me tell you why.

    Math doesn’t change. 10 mm today and tomorrow will be 1 cm. That will never change. A squared plus B squared will ALWAYS equal C squared. In a world where everything AND I DO MEAN EVERYTHING changes, math remains constant. I found it insanely calming at various points in my life. I had to take math every day in college, for all four semesters, and as much as I hated some of the units, I LOVED the class. It kept me sane. It calmed me down. It was a routine I could count on.

    The only A+ I ever got in a college course (not a test, but the whole course!) was Math.

    I

    Reply

  4. violet’s avatar

    I think my big problem here is not what he’s learning but.. how.

    Oldest One is extremely curious. He’ll spend HOURS regaling me with stories of how a certain thing works or acts or telling me about something that he learned.

    Multiple worksheets of numbers means nothing to him. He’s already learned the “look back at your earlier work and just use that” method! Which means he’s also not memorizing anything or figuring out how to do it, and when the method switches slightly, he freaks out. Cries. Loses his mind because it’s DIFFERENT.

    The problem is that school is.. catering to the lowest common denominator. THERE, I SAID IT. And there are too many kids to even attempt a personalization of the teaching beyond group work…

    And.. and.. and…

    Yargh.

    Reply

  5. Naomi’s avatar

    Violet –

    the others have given reasons for the math so I don’t need to go into that. If you are not seeing the point of the repetition, there are several options.

    First, if he thinks he has learned it, and doesn’t want to repeat all of them, let him not complete the sheets and take the consequence. Some children need the repetition, some do not. Tell him that, and by also doing the repetition, it helps those that do need it not to feel singled out.

    If he is freaking out because the method changes, then he clearly isn’t getting it. There are a lot of ways you can work with him to help him understand it. Manipulatives are good, as well as items to compare. If they are doing volume, for example, take out a container of milk. Ask him to estimate “how many containers of milk” do you think fit in the swimming pool, bedroom, etc. This will help give him a feel for the numbers, so he can “own” them, as it were.

    As well, when converting, be sure he identifies which unit is bigger / smaller, this will help him with which “direction” to move the decimal point.

    Take him to the grocery story, have him estimate masses of vegetables, for example, and then use the balance to see if he is right. Try to fit the measurements into your daily rituals.

    These concepts are difficult for students, and the repetition is actually good for them. They will need them all through middle and high school, and if they go into any profession needing math of any sort (mechanic, engineer, etc) they will need to be able to deal with conversions.

    The other thing it teaches them is that sometimes you need to do things you don’t like, and you need to do them well. THAT is a VERY good life lesson! *grin*

    Reply

  6. Nicholina’s avatar

    Just for a comment from the other side….I agree, Violet, that school does a disservice to most kids. The repetitious math is not engaging nor a good learning tool for a lot of kids.

    My 10 year old is bright, good with numbers and engaged in her learning. She’s learned math at her own pace because we’re unschoolers. I know she’s not missing out by not doing all the repetition. She knows the concepts and can figure most anything out.

    She didn’t have to learn to add multiple columns of digits before learning multiplication because we answered her questions as they came up.

    When she was 6, she knew more about fractions than her 10 year old cousin who was learning fractions in school mostly because we’d done a lot of cooking together.

    Now, when she took her 3rd grade assessment (required for homeschoolers in our state), she only did average in the section on math drill. However, she did well above average on applied math. Yeah, she doesn’t sit down and do endless worksheets, but she knows how to use math and is comfortable with it in the real world. Which is more important?

    I love math. I have a degree in computer engineering and math is a favorite of mine. I still disagree with the repetition and with having to learn math that has no relevance to your life.

    I’m worried about my 6 year old. He likes numbers and is good with them. He really dislikes the worksheets that he’s required to do for school. I worry that he’ll come to not love math because of being forced to do it. We’ll see.

    For now, I know that going to school is best for him. I worry that it’ll beat the love of learning out of him eventually, though.

    Reply

  7. Sylvain’s avatar

    I’m with Naomi on her last paragraph, big time!! I am so sick and tired of the lazy little snots our company has hired lately who seem to be lacking in this valuable life skill.
    Also, with math, I can’t tell you how many times I sat there wondering all through school “what the hell will I ever use this for?” I loved math, but seriously, why do I need to do fifty diferent variations of the same equation? I get it ok, can we move on??
    Then I decided to go into electronics in college. Yeah. Wow, it’s ALL math. ALL MATH. Calculous, Algebra, Physics. And I was glad I had had so much practice. I knew that all that repetition had worked, I could do some equations with my eyes closed and understood quickly the wihout thinking the difference between 9 ohms and .9 ohms or .09 ohms. I was top of my class in two courses. The groundwork is very important. It just doesn’t seem like it at the time.

    Reply

  8. Andrew’s avatar

    There is a point to conversion, really! No, I do not use decimeters, but as an engineer I AM forced to convert between all sorts of various units of measurement. And if he doesn’t learn how to convert between different Metric units, Lord help him if he has to deal with Imperial.

    The problem with education is that kids don’t know what they’re going to with their life professionally, so you have to teach everything. It’s OK thought… kids are sponges. :)

    Reply

  9. Theresa’s avatar

    Home Schooling might seem like a good idea on the actual education front but when you think about what else they learn in school – interaction with other kids, learning how to share, learning how to compromise, etc…this all comes from being in an environment with other people. People with other opinions, points of view, challenges.

    Plus, just being around other children their own age day in and day out is more fun and educational than being at home with Mom & Dad – and only Mom & Dad.

    Just learning to live in a world with other people is in itself, an education.

    I hope I didn’t offend. As you know, I’m not a parent. I’m just offering my POV.

    Reply

  10. Nicholina’s avatar

    That is a common misconception of homeschooling from the outside view. Homeschoolers have a wide range of socialization opportunities and are often better socialized than their public schooled counterparts.

    Why? Because they have the opportunity to socialize with a broad range of people of a variety of ages. Homeschoolers – at least most homeschoolers – are out in the world all day, not sitting at home. For us, our days are filled with Girl Scouts, swimming lessons, gymnastics, homeschool social group, a monthly homeschool class, a monthly homeschool book group, skiing, grocery shopping, game group, play dates, trips to the park, trips to the library. And, there is still time for just hanging out at home because the majority of the day isn’t being taken up by school.

    Think back to your school experience. How often did the teachers tell you, “You’re not here to socialize?”

    Reply

  11. Theresa’s avatar

    Good points. I didn’t think of that. Thanks for clearing that up.

    Reply