A bunch of things have collided together lately and prodded me into thinking more about the statement, “You’re not a mother; you wouldn’t understand”. I read it recently in a blog posting and I read it in a friend’s LJ entry and I’ve read variations of it, over the past many years, both online and off.
And, now that I am a mother, I know it’s totally a false statement.
Being a mother does not make you special. It does not make you different. It does not make you anything other than whatever you choose to let it make you. It does not suddenly make you smarter or prettier or wiser or more valid or more worthy. It does not make you more female or more nurturing or more loving or more patient. It doesn’t make you more responsible or give you all the answers.
I think the only universal is that it does make you more tired.
“Mother” applies to biological women who give birth, of course, but it’s also applied to biological women who adopt. It even extends to non-biological-women who adopt. It can be applied as a noun OR a verb. It can be applied to men, too. Right there, we’ve established that “being a mother” is not easily identified.
And if we use it as a verb – the action of “mothering” someone or something – we’re opening up a whole new envelope of goodness.
Every family is different. Every personality is different. Every mother is different. And every child is different.
So “mothering” in my household is not the same as “mothering” in your household.
Mothering can be hard. It can also be really easy. It can be instinctual or learned. It can be a big deal or a small deal. It can be a primary focus or a second-thought. It can be studied and read about and observed. It can seem magical. It can seem like pure drudgery. It can feel right or wrong or just plain ugly.
Before we adopted the kids, I had a good grasp of what “mothering” was going to mean in my world and, for the most part, my perceptions were correct. Like everything else in life, reality is just a matter of doing your research and visualizing and asking questions and keeping your eyes open.
And I think it does everyone a disservice to make “mothering” an exclusive club that you must experience in order to understand.
Everyone knows – or should know – that children are a gamble. There is no guarantee of temperament, attitude, height, weight, intelligence, gender, sleeping-habits, vegetable-eating, sanity, health, or any of the ‘standard features’ one expects from a child. There are birth defects and illnesses and genetic problems and, as most people know, much of the “problems” are the (bad) luck of the draw.
What you get is.. what you get.
And what you get, ultimately, will dictate the kind of parent you will be. The kind of mothering experience you’ll have will completely depend on how “lucky” you were – in ways you cannot control.
Even when you adopt a child, there are no guarantees. You know their gender and their appearance but.. what will come next is a complete surprise to everyone. Nature versus Nurture and all that.
I won’t disagree that, until you’ve lived through something day and night, 24/7, you can’t fully understand something on a visceral level. But your stressors and mine are two different things. What you find challenging may be easy for me. What you find easy may make me want to rend my own flesh. Your life education and experience is different from mine….
Do you know what it’s like to be me, the mother? No, because you don’t know what it’s like to be ME, in general. That’s just the way the world works.
I believe – truly – that the only time one can use the “you’re not a mother, you wouldn’t understand” line is if you make it read something like this:
You’re not a[n adoptive] mother [named Violet who has three kids and lives in my house with my husband and who has the family history, physical history, emotional history, chemical history, educational background, life experiences, memory of that day in 1980 when that kid was mean to me, ate a bagel for breakfast, once broke her leg falling down the stairs, fears (insert big list here) and loves (insert bigger list here) and once had an argument in the middle of a bookstore, experienced childhood in a particular location and at a particular time...] and so, y’know, you wouldn’t understand.
I have to stop now. I’m getting all ranty.



Recent Comments.